Discontent in the Happy Valley

“…I find one day and one hour exactly like another, except that the latter is still more tedious than the former. Let your experience inform me how the day may now seem as short as in my childhood, while nature was yet fresh, and every moment shewed me what I never had observed before.”

Rasselas, after a period of time between a realization that he needed to somehow find his way out to explore the world and find his own way:

“…but the months that have passed since new light darted into my soul, […] have been squandered by my own fault. I have lost that which can never be restored….”

‘Nothing, replied the artist, will ever be attempted if all possible objections must be first overcome.’

—Samuel Johnson, The History of Rasselas, Prince of Abissinia

When I began my bachelor’s degree at a non-traditional age, my very first class was Western Classics II at 8:00 on a Tuesday morning. I have always enjoyed books and the stories they hold but have never been a voracious reader, devouring books for purely entertainment. I have been long been one to mark and underline — annotating the text just as I annotate life.

The first book assigned to us was Samuel Johnson’s The History of Rasselas, Prince of Abissinia. (The title of this post is taken from the heading of Chapter 2.) As long ago as it was first published (1759), it was new for me. Although I could read for and process the ideas our professor was guiding us through, it was impossible for me to ignore several deep personal messages sent from the story to me. Our progressive and combined life experiences create a unique filter through which we process anything new that comes into our life. From the outside, most who knew the basics of my life would have assumed me to be content in the happy valley where I live. (I wrote the name of my town with a ? beside it the first time I came to that label —always italicized in the text— for the palace and grounds where Rasselas lived.) The discontent of Rasselas, though different from my own, and his quest to breach the walls of the happy valley to explore all the world held and to find his own choice of life (also always italicized) brought oxygen to a tiny little flame within me that had never been extinguished. And it began to grow.

I was very much at a point in life where I still felt trapped although I had taken one very important step toward making my life better: Going back to school. The obstacles to taking subsequent steps seemed overwhelming. And there was much beauty in my life even with the ugly that I kept secret. But the rumblings had begun. Scary as they were, I knew they were Good.

This post would be far too long if I shared every bit of text I underlined or highlighted. It is enough for me to put these thoughts down here and to turn back the pages of the book to read my thoughts and think about why I underlined and highlighted specific phrases, lines, or passages. The books I read over the next few years all are now like photo albums for me — full with images these markings evoke within my mind.

Taking a Step

“What saves a man is to take a step. Then another step. It is always the same step, but you have to take it.”

Antoine de Saint-Exupéry, Wind, Sand and Stars

This post does not address a truth gleaned from fiction as this book is a philosophical memoir, but it does begin a series of posts that mostly fit the theme of this blog. If you have only read The Little Prince, you need to find one of Antoine de Saint-Exupéry’s other books and read how much more wisdom this man has to share — from his own words and those of others he shared his incredible life with. In the past 10 years or so, he has become a favorite writer of mine.

Wind, Sand and Stars holds not only the quote above, but another of my favorite quotes of his: “A garden wall at home may enclose more secrets than the Great Wall of China.” The bittersweet beauty of that truth stays with me every day of my life. We do not and should not share everything that happens behind the walls of our home. But there are some secrets that should not be kept for the health of all who live within a home. How often do we take a walk, especially in the evening, and see a home lit from within and assume it is a happy home? How often have we heard news that informed us otherwise? How often, then, must it be true that the picket fences, the landscaping, the carefully chosen front doors enclose secrets we would never imagine.

There was a time in my life when I knew I needed to take a step. I had no idea how to take the step, but I kicked out my foot anyway. Each day, I keep taking that step. For too many years, I kept my feet planted in a place where I felt incapable of being authentic. What seems even more sad to me at times is that I don’t think I always realized that. I existed. When I needed to take that step, there are a few books (and authors) that helped to guide me into my first steps back to my self.

Although Wind, Sand and Stars is not one of those books, it did come to me at a time when I needed a reminder to keep taking the step. This is why I am choosing this quote to begin a series of posts on the truths that came to me from the pages of fiction at a time in my life when I profoundly needed them if I was to step beyond mere existence into an authentic and vivacious life. It has been quite a journey — one that continues.

The Past in our Present

10. Just because people aren’t in our lives anymore, doesn’t mean they stop thinking about us and vice versa.

— Wendy Mass, Jeremy Fink and the Meaning of Life

This is from Jeremy’s first entry in his community service reflection notebook. We could all learn from Jeremy’s drive to learn more about the back-stories of the people he meets in the course of his community service assignment. He, along with his best friend, are to return items pawned long ago by young people who felt they were at a crisis point in their lives — much like Jeremy feels he is in at the start of this story.

There are many poignant lines I could write about from this book, but yesterday this one seemed highlighted on the page for my eyes and heart. The sequence intrigues me. There are people who were part of our lives in our past whose impact is embossed within us. It doesn’t matter if the relationship was deep or surface, long-lasting or brief. If we continue to think of them, why do we often assume they never think of us too? Here, the emphasis is on others continuing to think about us before the vice versa.

I love the stories of the people I most cherish because I know the characters, the real people, from their life are woven together with all of the other characteristics I treasure. Granted, the stories that shape who we are now are not always pretty — this is real life — but the hardest times in life can enrich us like nothing else if we do not allow them to make us bitter or sour. Now I wonder even more how my presence in the lives of people from my past impacts who they are now and the stories they share.

As usual, my thoughts have wandered…..

No Ribbon Needed

Somehow or other, it came just the same!

And the Grinch, with his grinch-feet ice-cold in the snow, Stood puzzling and puzzling: “How could it be so? It came without ribbons! It came without tags! It came without packages, boxes or bags!”

Then the Grinch thought of something he hadn’t before! “Maybe __________ ,” he thought, “doesn’t come from a store.”

— Dr. Seuss, How the Grinch Stole Christmas

When I was a little girl, one of the best parts of Christmas was wrapping Dad’s present for Mom. I found so much joy in choosing the perfect wrapping paper and in making bows from curling ribbon that I just knew were way more awesome than any found in a store. What I treasure in this memory has nothing to do with any of the things in the packages, just as my gaudy ribbon bows did not add any tangible value to the gift they embellished. (However, that my dad always asked me to do this —even his last Christmas with us four years ago— was and still is a precious gift and memory.)

I still enjoy many of the sights and sounds and smells of this Christmas season, but not when they become the focus or are used to cover truth. Yesterday while traveling, I began thinking about the made-for-television version of How the Grinch Stole Christmas, and decided to read the book again. Through the years, the story of the Grinch’s attempt to steal Christmas from the Whos down in Who-ville has come to have meaning for me far beyond the obvious. Thus, my decision to use the ___________ in place of Christmas in the quote above.

More and more I see that what is essential to our joy, our happiness, our contentment, our celebrations, our love of who we are ourselves as well as our love for those who share life with us, cannot be purchased or packaged. Try as we might to find just the right anything to give ourselves or others true joy, whether through material gift or gesture or words, it is never the thing that will give real joy — regardless of any ribbons or colorful packaging.

Just as was true for the fictional Whos, I believe that which brings the richest joy to life is authentic relationship. The Whos needed only the presence of each other, hand-in-hand, to have joy and reason to celebrate through their singing together. There is no store where this can be found. There is no way to package or wrap this or any place to add a ribbon. Beautiful even so, yes?

The story of the Grinch’s foiled plan holds a deep truth for every day.

Facing Trouble

“Look here…don’t let’s beat about the bush: half the trouble in life is caused by pretending there isn’t any.”

—Edith Wharton, The House of Mirth

Several of the quotes I have written about have challenged me to address fragile places within my very core. The challenge for me in this truth is so multifaceted that I could probably write an entire book rather than a blog post. I have been sitting with this draft for several weeks, unsure about what I need to say to myself.

Almost all of us pretend at some point or on some level that our life is somehow different from what it really is. When we hide real trouble, in essence pretending that there is none, that trouble can fester and grow—making way for new or related troubles to develop. Physical, relationship, money, job…this truth covers all trouble.

For me, the reason I pretend trouble doesn’t exist is generally because I don’t want it to; I want it to go away. This has never happened. It can seem an easier option to go through the motions of life, finding a precarious balance of contentment in tending to the daily familiar even as we know we are missing a depth and richness we long for deep inside. Not knowing what could/might/will happen when we honestly face real troubles is beyond scary.

For some of us, there are plenty of joys even in this kind of life. I am thankful that I have always been one to see beauty and good in each day. Being able to still do that but at the same time not fear facing and dealing with hard realities is still new for me. I’ll keep practicing, because pretending there are no troubles does not make the troubles go away and can make them increase.

 

Seeing Beyond the External

Space is not the measure of distance. A garden wall at home may enclose more secrets than the Great Wall of China.

—Antoine de Saint-Exupéry, Wind, Sand and Stars

Be kind, for everyone you meet is fighting a battle you know nothing about.

—Wendy Mass, The Candymakers (*)

“Things are always what they seem to be, Reuven? Since when?”

—Chaim Potok, The Chosen

It is only with the heart that one can see rightly; what is essential is invisible to the eye.

—Antoine de Saint-Exupéry, The Little Prince

May I be even more aware of the truth expressed in these words.

*This quote is a paraphrase of one often attributed to Plato or Philo or several others: “Be kind, for everyone you meet is fighting a hard battle.” Its truth is not dependent upon who first said it.

My Choice: Fortunate over Unfortunate

In Chaim Potok’s The Chosen, Danny hits a softball right at Reuven’s face. The ball breaks Reuven’s glasses, and the shards lodge in and scratch his eye – sending Reuven to the hospital. The friendship that develops between these two Jewish teens from very different backgrounds (Danny is Hasidic, Reuven a liberal Orthodox) following Danny’s visits to Reuven in the hospital is beyond beautiful. It grows into a relationship that is essential for both of them. There are so many beautiful layers in this story, just as in any of Potok’s stories. (Read the book.) Keep the beauty of this friendship in mind as you read the passage I’ve been thinking of quite a bit lately:

When Reuven’s doctor suggest he get out of bed to walk around a bit, he stands for a time at a window just watching the people walking around outside. His father comes to visit him later:

“You will not be able to read for about ten days. He told me he will know by then about the scar tissue.”

“I’ll be happy to be out of this hospital,” I said. “I walked around a little today and saw the people on the street outside.”

My father looked at me and didn’t say anything.

“I wish I was outside now,” I said. “I envy them being able to walk around like that. They don’t know how lucky they are.”

“No one knows he is fortunate until he becomes unfortunate,” my father said quietly. “That is the way the world is.”

Reuven did not realize the fortune of his sight in both eyes until the sight in one was lost for a time. The people walking outside the hospital, likewise, had no reason to realize their fortune. I did not quite realize the fortune – the gift – that simply walking was until I had an injury that kept it from me. In fact, what spurred this post was a thought on my drive home this evening…. “I want and need to go for a walk this evening — the weather is perfect, and the time outside in the world is just what I need. …. I can’t walk.” I immediately thought of this passage.

The thing is, as I thought about it and reread it, I realized that the opposite is equally true — and far more profound in my life right now than the inconvenience of temporarily not being able to walk easily or to run. The circumstance that nearly took Reuven’s vision in one eye gave him the gift of a priceless friendship. Reuven may not have realized the gift his sight was until it was lost for a time. He also did not realize how unfortunate he was in his lack of a friendship such as developed with Danny until he experienced it. While he only had one eye to see with, he began to see the essential far more clearly.

Treasures come into our lives when we least expect them, even in the midst of the most unlikely of circumstances.

This is a post that begs for edits….I’ve written this very fast as I felt compelled to get my thoughts written out even if in a rough form.

Tenacity or Stubbornness

I have been wrestling with this question in my mind and heart for over a week now. Plugging in the words to thesaurus.com pulls up some interesting things. One of the words given as definition for tenacity is stubbornness. However, the synonyms listed for tenacity include characteristics such as: chutzpah (Yiddish words are great), persistence, perseverance, steadfastness, grit, courage. When I plugged in stubbornness, the synonyms (other than perseverance) carried an overall different twist: inflexibility, obstinacy — followed by the animal comparisons – bullheadedness, doggedness, mulishness, and pigheadedness. This fascinated me as stubbornness was given as a definition for tenacity, but its synonyms carry very different images.

“Real courage is when you know you’re licked before you begin, but you begin anyway and see it through no matter what.”

— Harper Lee, To Kill a Mockingbird

“You were stubborn . . . and fought against the storm, which proved stronger than you: but we bow and yield to every breeze, and thus the gale passed harmlessly over our heads.”

— Aesop, from a version of “The Oak and the Reeds

For those who do not know this particular fable, Oak gives the Reeds grief for not standing tall and strong. When a strong wind comes, he falls – because of his rigidity – while the reeds merely dance in the winds and come out unscathed.

Interesting, isn’t it, that the mighty oak tree is often given as a positive example of tenacity with its deep tap root? When the fall, though, they fall hard.

I am stubborn — I am tenacious. I get the two confused sometimes, as I did over the course of the past two weeks. In months of training for my first long-distance race, I believe I had the best goal in my mind and heart. I knew a week before the race date that I was somehow injured, but I did not want to stop long enough to even let myself question to what degree. Even less did I want to let anyone around me know that deep inside I was really hurting. In the pain, I lost track of the purpose of the race. In my mind, I did not want to give up.

There are plenty of times in life when being tenacious through challenge (whatever the cause of the challenge – be it injury/pain, sickness, other people, hoops, red tape (or Red Book), _________) is a beautiful thing, just as in the passage from To Kill a Mockingbird that illustrates that sometimes we stick to something from the start regardless of the likely result. When that tenacity begins to evolve into sheer stubbornness, we can cripple ourselves — or even fall. Sometimes letting go, even when I know full well in both my head and my heart that I should, has seemed too hard. I did not fall, but in my stubbornness (of the inflexible/mulishness variety) I allowed myself to become physically compromised to the point where it will take time and much effort on my part to become strong again. What some others saw as a beautiful picture of sticking it out was really not so beautiful in reality. (The reality is that in this particular case, it was closer to foolish.) I do not like that I made my stubbornness out to be something very different in my own eyes as well as in the eyes of others. Now, though, is the time for me to be tenacious (more of the chutzpah/determination variety) as I do all I can to heal and become strong (hopefully stronger) again.

Funny how every time I write, I make connections that were never part of my initial thoughts….

 

 

Inexpressible Comfort of Feeling Safe

Oh, the comfort —the inexpressible comfort of feeling safe with a person —having neither to weigh thoughts nor measure words, but to pour them all out, just as they are, chaff and grain together; knowing that a faithful hand will take a sift them, keep what is worth keeping, and then with a breath of kindness, blow the rest away.
D. M. M. Craik, A Life for a Life

 

These words, with the deep truth they convey, need no elaboration from me. When I came across them for the first time, I had heard neither of the novel nor the author. Not surprisingly, it was quickly clear that she was primarily a poet. I will not likely do any more research or reading; this short passage is more than enough for me.

We couldn’t enjoy its loveliness any more if….

Look at that sea, girls—all silver and shadow and vision of things not seen. We couldn’t enjoy its loveliness any more if we had millions of dollars and ropes of diamonds.

Anne of Green Gables by L. M. Montgomery

There are three or four books in my library that I have read so many times that the covers are falling off and the pages are tattered. My copy of Anne looks as well-loved as the skin horse in The Velveteen Rabbit, but I cannot imagine reading about Anne from any other pages. When I need a book to read at night to put me to sleep, this is the book I most often reach for — not because it is boring but because it relaxes me. The characters are comfortable to me, perhaps because over the years they have become real in a different way from the people I share life with. As Richard Bach wrote in Illusions, “If you will practice being fictional for a while, you will understand that fictional characters are sometimes more real than people with bodies and heartbeats.” While the sadness of that quote never escapes me, because I believe we need real people with bodies and heartbeats and laughter and tears and good conversation to share life with, for many of us there are a few fictional characters who have become real for us in a way that shapes parts of who we are. As I think about this, I wonder if for some people other things in life work this way — for example, sports teams. Perhaps it can be anything in life that remains something of a constant while other aspects of our world are constantly changing.

The pages of each Anne book are filled with truths. I’m not really sure why this is the one I was thinking of this morning, except that when I find myself yearning or longing for something I do not have, these words and others from Anne echo in my heart. The beauty of the world around us — in whatever form that beauty takes (and sometime I will write about my thoughts on just that!) — is never lessened because of things we have or do not have. Anne is so right, the beauty sun rippling on water, the first rays of sun spreading over fog-dappled fields, the sun setting behind the green fields on the other side of the road in the evening, the first sliver of crescent moon after the dark nights of a new moon, the very first buds beginning to swell in Spring or the first leaf tinged with red as Autumn approaches, the swirl of cafe in the white foam of a beautiful cafe con leche in Spain, an older couple holding hands in downtown Madrid, the sound of shared laughter, a band that swings or a voice that really sings, Sibelius and Mahler and Strauss, tiny crocuses peeking up out of the brown grass, an emerald green bug or a frog on the driveway, reflections in the Shawnee Run creek….would not have been any more beautiful to my eyes and heart If I had “millions of dollars and ropes of diamonds.”

That said, I do believe that for Anne as well as for me beauty can be richer when shared. Anne’s outlook on the world and life was never quite understood or shared by the girls that entered her previously lonely life, but her appreciation for all the world around her was still increased by the entrance of their friendship into her life. She had a gift of seeing beyond the surface to the richer subtleties of life in the presence as well as the potential for the future. Yes, she yearned for puffed sleeves. But when she received them in the form of a very unexpected gift, she realized that what made them beautiful had nothing to do with the sleeves themselves — their greatest beauty was from the love from which the dress they were a part of had been given.

So many thoughts tumbling in and adding too many layers to the central thoughts of this morning. This means it’s time to close.